Islamic Students Association Hosts Town Hall To Address NYPD Surveillance

NYU Students Speak Out Against NYPD’s Surveillance of Muslim Students from NYU Local on Vimeo (By Jorge Morillo and McKenzie Beehler)

Reaction to the recently exposed NYPD surveillance of NYU’s Islamic community continued today as the Islamic Student Association hosted a Town Hall bringing together students, campus leaders, and faculty for a discussion of the controversy. After the event, students walked together to university president John Sexton’s Town Hall, where they called for a formal university statement condemning the NYPD’s actions.

The event, held in the Kimmel lobby, united students from a variety of religious and secular campus organizations in common outrage at the NYPD’s surveillance of Muslim student groups on campuses across the northeast, including NYU. Over 100 students sat on the Kimmel steps, while others watched from the 2nd floor.

Many of the students wore shirts reading “NYUnited” in large letters above the phrase “where liberty is, there is my university,” a take off a quote by Benjamin Franklin. Some held signs with messages decrying the NYPD’s actions: “Big Brother is Watching,” “NYPD Is Spying On Us” and “Students Deserve Privacy.”

Speaking from a podium at the base of Kimmel’s cascading staircase, professors and students from a variety of faiths and university programs addressed the controversy from a variety of perspectives. Most saw the surveillance as more than a religious issue, but rather indicative of larger national problems related to the tension between privacy and security.

Professor J. Ward Regan of the Liberal Studies Program made this clear when he opened his comments. “Generally, I’m relatively agnostic on matters of faith. I am not agnostic on matters of human rights,” he said. Regan cited the NYPD’s argument that “several convicted terrorists had been involved in Muslim student associations.” He went on, “by that logic, we should be spying on MBAs at the Stern Business School because bankers commit crimes!” Applause, cheers and laughter overtook the crowd.

Others spoke of the personal impact of the NYPD’s program. CAS Senior Tabassum Rahman read a letter to President Sexton in which she spoke of the psychological fear inspired by surveillance. Rahman said that with the knowledge that she may have been the subject of the NYPD’s information gathering, stepping out into public made her fear being watched. “No one wants to be included in an NYPD report,” she said.

The multi-faith nature of the event was particularly evident when Ariel Ennis, an NYU senior, took to the podium. “If my yarmulke didn’t give it away, I am Jewish,” Ennis began. Ennis is a member of Bridges Muslim-Jewish Interfaith Dialogue, through which students of each faith experience the other’s worship services and work together on community service project. “What that says is that despite religious differences, members of our communities can be friends,”Ennis said. He went on to read a passage from a work by Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel entitled “No Religion Is An Island:”

We may disagree about the ways of achieving fear and trembling, but the fear and trembling are the same. The demands are different, but the conscience is the same, and so is arrogance, iniquity. The proclamations are different, the callousness is the same, and so is the challenge we face in many moments of spiritual agony. Above all, while dogmas and forms of worship are divergent, God is the same.

The event attracted a wide audience. Marc Wais, Vice President for Student Affairs, sat for some time to the side of the staircase and listened to a number of the speakers. NY1 filmed outside Kimmel while a Wall Street Journal reporter spoke to attendees within.

After 13 speakers and a brief period of open comments, the students proceeded to John Sexton’s Town Hall on Greene Street. At the standing-room-only event, Islamic Students Association President Ahman Raza asked the first question. Before beginning, Raza asked NYUnited to rise, a large portion of the audience – perhaps 60 in total – stood quietly behind him.

“We ask that you publicly condemn the actions of the NYPD and ask them to what extent their surveillance was conducted here at NYU in the form of an official university statement, just like Rutgers, Yale, Hunter and Columbia have done. We also ask that you send a letter to students, alums, and parents assuring them that the university had no prior knowledge of the surveillance and that the community will be supported to the best of the University’s abilities.”

In typical Sexton fashion, the president did not arrive at his answer immediately. However, he ultimately stated that “We are doing everything that we can to ensure that there isn’t any inappropriate surveillance of our students. We don’t know of any yet.” Sexton said that Jules Martin, the head of Public Safety and a former NYPD officer, had been in communication with the NYPD and had found no evidence of surveillance. Further, Sexton stated, “I can say that there was not scintilla of cooperation on this campus. We learned about this at the same time that you learned about this.”

However, Sexton did not promise a formal university statement, saying instead, “this is being videotaped and posted. I’ve authorized you to use my letter publicly as much as you want. I have a personal stake in this.”

Sexton had previously addressed a letter [PDF] to NYPD Commissioner Ray Kelly, in which he wrote, “I must report our community’s alarm over the reports of this activity, and that we stand in fellowship with our Muslim students in expressing our community’s dismay.”

Precisely the nature and extent of the NYPD’s surveillance remains unseen. Earlier this week, NYU Local reported:

One of the NYPD’s classified cyber intelligence reports from November 2006 revealed that officers were trawling Muslim students’ websites as part of their “daily routine” as far back as six years ago. Included in the scheme was indeed the activities of the Muslim Community at NYU and many other universities across the city. A section of the report titled “Muslims Students Association/ Islamic Center of New York University,” details the speakers, attendees and promoters of events held by the Muslim community at NYU some years ago.

As calls for a federal investigation by Attorney General Eric Holder intensify and NYU’s Muslim community remains mobilized, this controversy is clearly far from resolved.


    Share Your Thoughts


  1. Elena Grontini says

    What can we – as informed citizens who desire peace – do about these terrible, unlawful actions committed by NYPD and federal authorities, under the one-size-fits all anti-Muslim hype? Why does the U.S government manufacture terror and fear (please read/watch the links below for documented, verified proof), cherry picking the Muslim community?? Where are the journalists who are supposed to connect these dots on our behalf? These are legitimate questions, are they not?

    I am surprised the NYU Islamic Student Association has not discussed this information in any article to this point, as it is very serious, especially considering that it is now public knowledge that the NYPD featured an anti-Muslim video as part of their training of officers.

    These links are all related to this article. Glenn is an NYU graduate and former Constitutional and civil rights litigator.

    1) The FBI Successfully Thwarts its own Terror Plot
    By Glenn Greenwald – (Glenn is an NYU grad)

    2) Former NYC Mayor Leans on NYU to Disavow Report on Terrorism
    The Chronicle of Higher Education
    October 8, 2011

    Edward I. Koch, a former New York City mayor, has called on the dean of New York University’s law school to disavow a report critical of terrorism prosecutions, according to The New York Times.

    The report, published in May by the (NYU) law school’s Center for Human Rights and Global Justice, accuses law-enforcement agencies of entrapping young Muslim men. It focuses on three prominent cases and characterizes the threat of domestic terrorism as “manufactured.”

    The Times says that prominent alumni of the law school recently brought the report to the attention of Mr. Koch, who is also a graduate, and that he urged the school’s dean, Richard L. Revesz, to disavow it. He also asked Mr. Revesz to distribute a rebuttal written at the former mayor’s urging by U.S. Rep. Peter T. King, a Republican of Long Island who has held controversial hearings on the radicalization of American Muslims. When Mr. Revesz refused, Mr. Koch decided to take his beef to the news media.

    3) Michigan lawyer couple say government created Christmas Day terror

    “The U.S. government escorted them through security without a passport and, we believe, gave him an intentionally defective bomb,” said Kurt Haskell.

  2. Steve Mei says

    “One of the saddest lessons of history is this: If we’ve been bamboozled long enough, we tend to reject any evidence of the bamboozle. We’re no longer interested in finding out the truth. The bamboozle has captured us. It is simply too painful to acknowledge ~ even to ourselves ~ that we’ve been so credulous. So the old bamboozles tend to persist as the new bamboozles rise.” ~Carl Sagan

  3. Sulayman Rumi says

    Really cool video, NYULocal! I couldn’t make the town hall or the teach-in, so I’m glad someone reported on it.

  4. Ganesha_akbar says

    The Muslim Student Association is a Muslim Brotherhood affiliate which the NYPD has been (quite appropriately) monitoring.

    Discover the Networks has documentation of the MSA’s ties to the Brotherhood, as well as a lengthy list of inflammatory, jihadist statements and jihad activities by MSA members.

    The relevant question is why Universities continue misallocating student funds to support MSA and their grotesque pro-Hamas propaganda campaigns?

  5. Brett Chamberlin says

    Ganesha, NYU’s student group is the Islamic Students Association, not the Muslim Students Association. Regardless, it’s not difficult to find a link between any student organization events which someone finds politically disagreeable. We could call the Catholic Club pro-pedophilia or fault the Japanese Students Group for the 1931 invasion of Manchuria. However, we don’t do that because we recognize that a) such a tactic is logically tenuous at best and b) universities and the student groups that they fund are intended to promote diverse and even competing ideas. Calling for the defunding of this group because of Hamas’ actions is no more valid than calling for the defunding of NYU’s far more numerous Jewish students associations over Israel’s continued violation of various UN resolutions and the Geneva Convention.