Entertainment - by Jessica Roy on Wednesday, September 10, 2008 10:24 - 5 Comments - 15 views

‘New York Times’ Reporters Are Dinosaurs

When I was in Denver for the DNC, I got stuck on one of the convention shuttles with a couple of New York Times reporters. Immediately, something struck me about them: good God, they were all so old.

The New York Times is a veritable journalistic institution and one of the most credible sources of information on this earth, but I am consistently shocked at the increasing amount of irrelevance that pervades its pages. As Ned mentioned in his article about New Media, there is a difference between true avant garde New Media, and simply making a web version of your print paper. Perhaps the Times does not pride itself on accurately gauging the pulse of the young American populous, but the trend pieces on fads that are literally three years old and the nagging notion that the reporters are constantly trying to prove that they are indeed relevant gets not only tiresome, but also mildly offensive.

The New York Times Magazine attempts to act as somewhat of a hip cultural counterpart to the otherwise dry news pages of the paper. They put interesting people on the cover and are constantly struggling to prove that even as Olds they know what the internetz is. Look, there’s Emily Gould half-naked with her laptop! Oh wow, this reporter knows how to navigate Facebook! And yet, every Saturday morning when it arrives on my doorstep, I open it to find the same old thing: more articulate articles about a topic some blog has already exhausted, both through original posts and guest comments.

My problem with the Times is not that they refuse to cater to a technological, self-absorbed generation that will inevitably hate on their well-researched pieces with a poorly spelled rant on Wordpress, but instead that they attempt to cater to our generation and fail miserably.

This week’s T Magazine included the piece by Clive Thompson, “I’m So Totally, Digitally Close to You,” an article about—you guessed it!—ways in which social networking sites are shifting real world dynamics. The thesis is interesting: the fact that we are all constantly connected has created an “ambient intimacy,” a feeling that we are close to each other without actually being physically close.

Surely this is something that millennials have recognized for ages: ambient intimacy is receiving a raving e-mail from a fan of your blog, or solely using AIM to talk to friends from high school who now live in different cities. This is not a fresh phenomenon to those of us who have grown up with it, so perhaps the Times’ obsession with social networking and its crucial impact on our lives reflects upon the fact that their staffers are indeed an extension of Old Media. Perhaps they do not fall asleep cradling a stack of sweetly smelling newspapers, waking up with ink dotting their crinkled cheeks, but there is something decidedly Old Guard about them that can be off-putting to young journalists who have always had faith in New Media and are looking to eradicate the negative thinking surrounding it.

But who can blame print for having an existential crisis? Most people get their news from blogs and other online sources these days, the idea of opening up a newspaper to learn about current events has receded into archaic nothingness along with beepers and Walkmen. The irony, then, is that it seems for once the kids have it all figured out—at least when “figured out” means freelancing for $300/week to afford your studio in BedStuy—and it’s the more established journalistic elite who are struggling for a respected place in this new world.

Photo: Flickr by wallyg used under Creative Commons

Share
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • TwitThis
  • Digg
  • Google
  • Fark
  • StumbleUpon
  • Tumblr


5 Comments

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Ned Resnikoff
Sep 10, 2008 14:36

I don’t know, I find these articles on things that have already happened fascinating. Articles like, Some People Really Like to Play World of WarCraft All the Time and The Internet Has a Lot of Stuff On It provide their own special insight into the mindset that birthed them.

Justin Spees
Sep 10, 2008 17:35

Maybe some people want to read articulate, thought provoking articles about new media issues rather than rants from some jackass with a blog.

NYU Local - Salvia Sought By Dumb Teenagers For Its Spiritual Revelations
Sep 10, 2008 18:32

[...] I promptly forgot about it.  So maybe the New York Times actually reported on something that was new and relevant to the youth demographic.  Or maybe I’m just [...]

Jessica Roy
Sep 11, 2008 4:25

Don’t get me wrong, I appreciate the NYT for what it is, just not what it’s trying to be. And there are many bloggers that are changing the landscape of the media, whether or not you think they are “jackasses.”

Nina Yiamsamatha
Sep 11, 2008 19:17

I found “I’m So Totally, Digitally Close to You” fascinating precisely because the NYT reporters are older. Their lives aren’t as consumed by the internet/blogs/social networking sites, whereas we’ve grown up peculiarly digital.

What’s interesting about Clive Thompson’s article is that it provides an outside (read: older) perspective. I thought his descriptions (especially of his experience with Twitter and the way people interact with their digital communities) were refreshing in a wow-I’ve-never-thought-of-it-like-that kind of way. I mean, this “ambient intimacy/co-existence/awareness” results from our growing tendency to digitally broadcast our lives to our entire Facebook-MySpace-Twitter- “network.” And it’s also this tendency that gets your opinions on NYULocal published, read, and responded to.

We may be on the edge of New Media and the web, but I think it’s interesting to watch as the NYT tries catch up.

Leave a Reply

Our Policy on Comments

Comment

Buy viagra without prescription phentermine no prescription ambien no prescription xanax no prescription diazepam no prescription alprazolam no prescription valium no prescription clomid no prescription reductil no prescription meridia no prescription nexium no prescription zolpidem no prescription topamax no prescription tramadol no prescription ultram no prescription soma no prescription prednisone no prescription lipitor no prescription glucophage no prescription lorazepam no prescription buy discount viagra cheapest generic viagra viagra sale online buy generic cialis cheapest cialis no prescription purchase valtrex no prescription cheap nolvadex no prescription buy clomid no prescription purchase xenical no prescription zantac online no prescription order zithromax cheap cialis order viagra buy levitra online cheap lаsix Buy Viagra No Prescription Buy Orlistat Buy Alli Buy Xenical Buy viagra without prescription cialis without prescription viagra without prescription propecia without prescription levitra without prescription soma without prescription zithromax without prescription acomplia without prescription lasix without prescription accutane without prescription altace without prescription claritin without prescription zanaflex without prescription buy viagra order viagra cheap viagra buy cialis ! order cialis ! cheap cialis buy propecia order propecia cheap propecia buy levitra ! order levitra cheap levitra alprazolam online phentermine without prescription phentermine online klonopin without prescription klonopin online ativan without prescription ativan online meridia without prescription meridia online xenical without prescription xenical online tamiflu without prescription tamiflu online lipitor without prescription lipitor online diazepam without prescription diazepam online lexapro without prescription lexapro online alprazolam without prescription alprazolam online lorazepam without prescription lorazepam online clonazepam without prescription clonazepam online buy viagra order viagra cheap viagra buy levitra order levitra cheap levitra buy cialis order cialis cheap cialis buy propecia order propecia cheap propecia buy acomplia order acomplia cheap acomplia buy accutane order accutane cheap accutane buy xenical order xenical cheap xenical