Village Zoning Laws Pass, Put A Cap On NYU’s Vertical Expansion

NYU is officially vertically challenged. As of yesterday, there is a chunk of the East Village in which no structure of Founder’s-esque proportions will ever rise again. The brand-new rezoning, effective immediately, puts a cap on all future building heights at 12 stories (less than half of Third North) within eight blocks between 3rd and 4th Avenues, from East 9th to East 14th Streets.

To compensate for newly finite floorspace, the rezoning includes an allowance for greater density in residential buildings, provided the developers commit 20% of the area of a new building to low-income housing.

Still, though, we wondered what this could mean for rent prices in the future. With demand for East Village apartments not subsiding any time soon, it seems logical (reductive, certainly, but still) that at some point rent would respond to the lack of supply.

Andrew Berman, the head of the Greenwich Village Society for Historic Preservation, told us he feels this just isn’t so. “In areas where we have not gotten zoning changes and many new, big fancy high-rises have gone up, we have seen prices escalate the fastest.”

The rezoning was first proposed in 2005 by the GVSHP in direct response to the construction plans for Founder’s Hall, but never made it through City Council. Berman’s email blast today was dotted with all-caps ecstaticism — “WHICH MEANS THEY TAKE IMMEDIATE EFFECT!” – but he told us that the rezoning fell short of his hopes. ”In the case of 3rd and 4th Avenue, we wanted something much more restrictive. But this is as far as City Planning was willing to go.”

Although nothing in NYU’s 2031 expansion plans mentions developing in this patch of blocks, the neighborhood is certainly within ideal range of Washington Square Park to have been prime expansion turf, before yesterday. The decision, which also includes a similar rezoning of a section of the far West Village, may be establishing a legislative precedence for other such height limits in areas desirable to university expansion. It may even be on the minds of committee members when they vote on NYU’s 40-story pinwheel tower in November.

In a city where airspace is everything, the ability to stunt vertical aspiration may be a community’s most powerful tool. It can also sink a university ship.



7 Comments

  • Blake Peterson
    October 28, 2010

    Third north is only 14 stories

  • Blake Peterson
    October 28, 2010

    Also thrid north isn’t even located in the blocks specified…I think the writer meant founders.

  • Zoë Schlanger
    October 28, 2010

    @Blake- you’re totally right. Fixed. …I should sleep more.

  • Zoë Schlanger
    October 28, 2010

    @Blake-Also,Third North is within the blocks that got rezoned, so there won’t be any more third northian buildings in the area again either.

  • Blake Peterson
    October 28, 2010

    Lol I didn’t even realize you wrote this article…good job!

  • Phillip Klugman
    October 29, 2010

    I think people fail to realize that if NYU didn’t buy Founders Hall, there would still be a building in that space that is just as tall. The only difference would be no church facade in front of the building and possibly a larger building that comes farther towards the curb.

  • [...] residential development in mixed buildings.” And developer bonus: there are absolutely no height restrictions in the area, so a glassy new high-rise by next year is virtually guaranteed.This divey go-to will [...]

Leave a Reply

Commenting for the first time? Your comment may not appear immediately, so please be patient. See our policy on comments.